Travelling abroad often makes you crave your favorite hometown and All-American meals. Visiting Windsor and London with our daughter recently was tons of fun but by around day three, we’d had our fill of potatoes, sausage, runny eggs, limp bacon, mushy peas, and anything boiled. Upon arrival back home, we immediately treated ourselves to some good ole Tex-Mex and our bellies were so happy and said “muchas gracias!”
Truth be told I’m not a diehard foodie, but what I love, I love. One thing I love is a good sandwich, which was something we sorely missed in England. My favorite sandwiches are simple: chicken or tuna salad, grilled cheese, and a classic peanut butter and jelly. Okay, I also like a good cheesesteak sandwich. If it were up to me, sandwiches would be on our menu every week. You could call me the Queen of Sandwiches!
Amazingly, royalty is to thank for the beloved sandwich, which fits in perfectly with my memories of our trip. Apparently, the Earl of Sandwich is credited with inventing the sandwich, hence the name. Who knew?! The Earl wanted to eat his meals with one hand during a gambling event and instructed his servant to put his meat between two slices of bread. Voila! The sandwich was born. You literally can’t make this stuff up.
Okay, so meat and cheese on bread. Got it. But how in the world did peanut butter and jelly come to be? I LOVE peanut butter (creamy only please) so I was fascinated to find out the history of one of my favorite sandwiches.
First had to come the bread, specifically sliced, which we can thank Otto Frederick Rohwedder for, as he invented the bread slicer in the early 1900s, deeming it “the greatest thing since sliced bread.” Again, you can’t make this stuff up.
Jelly is also of course important here. Paul Welch secured a patent for pureeing grapes and turning them into jelly in 1917. I remember years ago driving from Buffalo to Cleveland and seeing what I thought were vineyards, only to be told it was all property of Welch’s and all of which would be turned into jelly, jam, or preserves. Speaking of all of those, let’s review quickly the differences between them.
Jelly is made using only the juice of the fruit and sugar and is the firmest and smoothest product of the bunch. Jam, on the other hand, is made from whole or cut fruits and then cooked to a pulp with sugar, producing a thick, fruity, spread. Its texture is usually looser and more spoonable than jelly. Lastly, preserves and marmalade. Preserves contain the most physical fruit of the bunch and are sometimes held together in a loose syrup; other times, the liquid is more jammy. Marmalade is simply the name for preserves made with citrus. It is similar to jam but made only from bitter Seville oranges from Spain or Portugal. The name of Marmalade originates from the Portuguese Marmelos, which is a quince paste similar in texture to an orange spread. I prefer a good jam on my PB&Js.
Okay, now for the P of those PB&Js.
The National Peanut Board reports the forerunner of the peanut butter we know and love today was first established in the 1880s when Dr. Ambrose Straub from St. Louis made a peanut paste for older patients struggling with swallowing or who had bad teeth and couldn’t chew well. Around that same time, Dr. John Harvey Kellogg (yep, that Kellogg) patented a process for manufacturing peanut butter. Introduced to the masses at the 1893 Chicago World Fair, you could say it all went viral when Straub partnered with a food company and took it to the St. Louis World Fair. Soon after, grocery stores began ordering it and shoppers discovered its magic.
Oddly enough, and again a somewhat tie-in with my recent London trip, peanut butter initially was considered and upscale food and was often offered in New York City tea rooms. For years, today’s staple was considered a delicacy.
Putting all three parts together…the bread, jelly, and peanut butter…into a sandwich came to be in 1901 when Julia Davis Chandler wrote a recipe for in the Boston Cooking School Magazine of Culinary Science and Domestic Economics. But it literally took a war to bring it to the masses.
During the Great Depression of the 1930s, families did discover peanut butter as a satisfying and affordable nourishment but the event that put the peanut butter and jelly sandwich on the map was World War II.
Sometimes necessity breeds brilliance, and that was somewhat the case when peanut butter and jelly were included on U.S. Military ration menus during the war. Military minds discovered peanut butter was a high-protein, shelf-stable ingredient that was also easily portable on long marches and soldiers discovered its tasty taste. When soldiers came home from the war, they spread the word on the tasty spread and sales of both peanut butter and jelly soared. Kids loved it because it’s yummy, parents loved how easy it was to make, and the economy loved it because the making of it created incomes and jobs.
Hard to believe one of my beloved sandwiches has such an interesting history. It may look like something simple, which it is, but in between those slices of bread smothered with peanut butter and jelly is royalty, creative minds, and even a war. Sounds to me like a PB&J is fit for a king!